
NOTES FROM NATURE
By Jerry Toll
Consider the Bowerbirds
Now this is a family of birds I can relate to. They are
builders, artists, dancers, painters, and individualists. Am I
anthropomorphizing? Yes, flagrantly so, but I will offer these
observations in my defense.
The bowerbirds, with 8 species in Australia and 18
species in New Guinea, make up the family Ptiloinorhynchidae. As builders,
they are unique in the bird world.
The males of each species construct mating grounds to
attract females. For the Spotted Bowerbird, it's a simple avenue (bower).
The male constructs a tightly woven horizontal mat of grass or twigs. He
then weaves vertical twigs into the mat so that they form an arch over a
central straight pathway or avenue. After this he finds white objects such
as bits of bones, rocks, and snail shells and places them, carefully, to
one side of the avenue.
The male of this species favors white objects and rejects
red, yellow, and blue objects. However, he then masticates something that
when mixed with his saliva produces a reddish substance he paints onto the
objects in the bower.
The female enters the avenue and looks through it to the
placement of the white objects. Meanwhile the male is watching, somewhat
hidden. If the female likes what she sees, she signals the male, he
reveals himself and does a little dance, sometimes with a song. If she
still likes what she sees, they leave the bower and mate.
His part in the continuation of the species is to attract
as many females as possible to his bower, retain them and mate. If he
fails to do this, his genes will not be passed on and will eventually die
out. In other words, how well he expresses himself determines the survival
of his gene pool. I'll come back to this.
Most species of bowerbirds are polygynous. Of these, the
complexity of the bower construction is inversely related to the
elaboration of the males' breeding plumage. The genus of Gardener
Bowerbirds produces larger and more elaborate structures. Due to lack of
space, I wont' describe each of the species' bowers, but they have certain
characteristics in common. For each of the species, the form of the bower
is hard-wired in their brains, but the selection and placement of objects
is highly variable and seems extremely important to the success of the
enterprise.
I had the pleasure of watching a PBS Nova program
on the bowerbirds presented by David Attenborough, which led to this
article. What struck me as fascinating when I watched the Gardener
Bowerbird arranging his arena was his "expression," if I may use that
word, or perhaps his body language.
I have seen that same expression on the face of an artist
during the act of creation. It posed this question, "Is this bird
demonstrating artistic expression?" Or, conversely, is there an instinctual predisposition to
artistic expression that humans share with other creatures on our planet?
The most basic definition of art is a creative act by an
individual. This has been attributed exclusively to humans in the past,
but behavioral biologists and cultural anthropologists have been chipping
away at the wall that separates the attributes of humans and animals.
Let's not forget the role of the female in this drama.
The female as well as male of each species has developed artistic
inclinations. It is she who must have the discerning eye. It is she who
determines whether the elaborate preparations the male has made for her
are acceptable. She determines successful mating. In doing so, she
reinforces the genetic predisposition of the practice.
What have these elaborate mating rituals to do with
survival of the species? Very little, it seems. She takes full
responsibility for rearing young. She determines whether the species will
continue to reproduce itself in sufficient numbers to thrive.
There are many things creatures do even though related to
reproduction that are seemingly frivolous or unnecessary, sometimes even
downright contradictory.
I think this is Nature's way of saying that orderliness
is elusive. That, yes, there is order in the universe but it is not linear.
We must search for it in creative ways, ways that might make no sense
until we make the slender connection.
The purpose of the bowerbirds' mating rituals is to
provide uniqueness. It defines the species. It tells them who they are.

Previous Notes from Nature:
01/24/08